ESOP Tax Credit Research Project

Examining the causal effect of Colorado's HB17-1214 on firm-level ESOP participation and asset accumulation

Project Overview

This research project examines the causal effect of Colorado's HB17-1214, an employee ownership support program enacted in 2017, on firm-level ESOP participation and asset accumulation.

Research Question: What is the effect of Colorado's HB17-1214 employee ownership support program on firm-level ESOP participation and asset accumulation?

Access the Full Report

Key Findings

Our analysis using Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (2012-2025) with a difference-in-differences design comparing Colorado to Utah reveals:

Our findings suggest education-based and financing-focused employee ownership policies may require longer time horizons or more direct financial incentives to generate substantial ESOP adoption among small and medium-sized businesses.

Policy Context

Colorado's HB17-1214 (signed by Governor Hickenlooper in 2017) focused on:

Reported outcomes: 20-25 businesses per year transitioned to employee ownership with program support.

Methodology

Difference-in-Differences (DiD)

We compare Colorado firms (treatment, post-2017) to Utah firms (control) and Colorado firms (pre-2017) before and after the 2017 policy implementation. This removes time-invariant differences between states and common macroeconomic shocks.

Identification Assumptions

Robustness Check

Synthetic control methodology constructing counterfactual "synthetic Colorado" from weighted combinations of other U.S. states (Iowa and Missouri excluded due to own ESOP legislation).

Important Limitations